Turkey constructed a wall of denialism – Forbes on Armenian Genocide themed “The Promise”
Author of the American Forbes magazine Stefan Ihrig has published an article on the Armenian Genocide themed movie “The Promise” and about the denial atmosphere surrounding it.
STEPANAKERT, NOVEMBER 15, ARTSAKHPRESS-ARMENPRESS: Ihrig titled the article “Genocide Denial Goes Viral: 'The Promise' And The IMDB”.
The author says speaking about the Armenian Genocide one becomes the target for Turkish nationalists and deniers.
“Writing this is dangerous: Speaking out on the Armenian Genocide means taking a huge risk. At the very least, it will be an exhausting experience, getting harassed online, trolled, threatened, down-rated on Amazon and publicly vilified. Until now, this was true mainly for individuals—academics, artists and activists, “he writes.
Later in the article Ihrig discusses the recent Turkish protests over a concert in Germany:
“Just in the last weeks, Turkey left the European Union’s cultural program in protest over a piece honoring the victims of the genocide by the Dresden Symphonic Orchestra which was sponsored by the program. Most recently, Turkey prevented a concert—again the very same piece—at the German Consulate in Istanbul. And now, we are in the middle of the next anti-Armenian campaign. This time its object is a Hollywood movie, The Promise, an epic focusing on the Armenian Genocide, starring amongst others Christian Bale. Yet, this time it might actually backfire and go another way.”
The article also presents the past efforts of Turkey of failing Armenian Genocide themed movies in Hollywood.
“All this has a long tradition. Eighty years ago the Turkish government forced Hollywood to drop a movie project based on The Forty Days of Musa Dagh, then a best-selling novel on the Armenian Genocide by German-language author, Jew and outspoken Hitler opponent Franz Werfel. The Forty Days of Musa Dagh, originally written as a warning against Hitler through the prism of the Armenian Genocide, never saw the silver screen. Such a movie could have also raised awareness of the fate of the Jews in Nazi Germany at the time and later of the ongoing Holocaust. It could have shaped the “narrative” of the struggle against Hitler. Many have since been interested to finally turn the novel into a major production, most recently, for example, Mel Gibson and Sylvester Stallone, but Turkish opposition and obstruction seemed insurmountable”, the article reads.
“The Turkish government has constructed a very solid and relatively successful wall of enforced silence, blocking attempts not only to acknowledge, but even to discuss the topic through various forms of intimidation. Even if methods of intervention have changed, Turkish denialism is not a thing of the past. It is less often direct intervention by the government or the embassy, but rather a general atmosphere of intimidation, fear and enforced silence”, Stefan Ihrig says.
Speaking about “The Promise”, Stefan Ihrig says the movie made it further than the past projects mainly because of independent financing. He says it is one of the most expensive independently financed movies so far.
“The movie was screened in September at the Toronto International Film Festival to rather small-sized audiences. Like any movie of note, it has its IMDB entry ready where you can find all the information on the movie and where people can rate the film from one star to ten. And here this movie, for all intents and purposes is not yet available to the public, has become something of an online sensation, or rather an online battlefield. Over the last weeks it has attracted over 91,000 votes, largely split between ten- and one-star votes. The majority, over 57,000, are one-star votes. This is an obvious campaign to downrate the movie which then triggered pro-Armenian voting. We are witnessing yet another anti-Armenian denialist campaign playing out abroad, far away from Turkey, in open, democratic societies. While it is not clear who is orchestrating the campaign, it has to be assumed that, as with other campaigns, connections go back to the Turkish government and/or nationalist groups.
Armenian Genocide denialism has gone through various phases of development in the last decades. Denialism has entered the age of Twitter and online mob-rule. And, unfortunately, quite successfully so”, he wrote.
- 17:41 Iraq forces launch offensive on western districts of Mosul
- 16:54 NSW Premier Gladys Berejiklian meets with Israel’s Netanyahu
- 15:42 Armenia MOD: Azerbaijan defense minister is more accustomed to role of military company commander
- 15:28 Armenia president to meet with NATO Secretary General
- 15:16 Armenia President bestows posthumous award upon military officer
- 14:27 Karvachar will soon have 24-hour drinking and irrigation water supply
- 13:29 Nagorno Karabakh military mocks another Azerbaijani disinformation
- 12:44 Azerbaijan ambassador attempts to intimidate Bulgarians, regarding Karabakh
- 12:10 Czech MEP: I visited Karabakh in 1990s as journalist, this time—as politician
- 11:43 This is a step that completes the process of independence. François Rochebloine
- 09:33 “This is not how mature countries conduct their business” – MEP Soraya Post concerned over Azerbaijan’s behavior towards her colleagues
- 09:28 Azerbaijani forces fire hundreds of rounds at NKR posts in past 24 hours
- 17:51 Armenian Assembly of America congratulates Artsakh on Referendum
- 16:36 Azerbaijan is preparing another provocation: Senor Hasratyan
- 14:50 Azerbaijan’s aspiration for absurd and illogical steps is unlimited: Artsakh FM
- 13:44 Criminalizing visits to Artsakh is a threat to Russia's national security and territorial integrity - Denis Dvornikov
- 13:06 Armenia official: Baku declaring international search for MEPs is ridiculous
- 12:17 ICRC representatives visit blogger Lapshin in Baku
- 12:12 Elton John to Introduce Armenian Genocide Film
- 12:12 Armenia Police: MEPs mentioned by Azerbaijan are not wanted by Interpol
- 11:15 Armenian FM meets with Russian journalists in Moscow
- 10:51 Nagorno Karabakh soldier shot dead
- 10:16 President of Nagorno Karabakh addresses congratulatory message on Fatherland Defender Day
- 09:48 Nagorno Karabakh forces take countermeasures to suppress Azerbaijani mortar & cannon attacks
- 18:13 France-Artsakh friendship circle welcomed Francois Hollande's statement about Nagorno Karabakh
- 17:27 Russian citizens can visit Armenia with internal passports starting from February 23
- 16:59 Nalbandian finds it bizarre for Azerbaijan to talk about humanitarianism after decapitating Armenian soldier
- 16:33 No alternative to Minsk Group co-chairmanship format on NK conflict – says Russia’s Lavrov
- 15:49 Lavrov: Russia not indifferent to fate of Yerevan OSCE office
- 15:08 Russia FM accepts Armenia counterpart’s invitation
- 14:18 Armenia FM’s Russia official visit kicks off
- 13:24 Armenian artists take part in Surajkund International Crafts Mela in India
- 12:04 Argentina MP is impressed by Karabakh constitutional referendum voting process
- 11:28 Armenia’s Defense Minister criticizes Turkey’s policy in South Caucasus
- 11:15 Defense minister Sargsyan mentions Iskander engagement conditions
- 10:48 Nagorno Karabakh defense ministry denies Azerbaijani report on infiltration attempt
- 10:09 NK conflict settlement to be important part of Lavrov-Nalbandian talks: Russian foreign ministry
- 09:48 Azerbaijani forces open intense mortar, cannon fire in Nagorno Karabakh ceasefire breach
- 21:14 NKR Foreign Minister, delegation of Basque Country discuss future cooperation
- 19:47 Reluctance of Azerbaijan to recognize democratic development of Artsakh is failed attempt to return to past. NKR MFA
- 18:18 Artsakh can serve as an example for countries of the South Caucasus: Rodrigo Garcia Gomez
- 17:51 Azerbaijan is far from democracy. Representative of California
- 17:47 Artsakh is more developed and democratic country than Azerbaijan. Manuel Ochsenreiter
- 17:33 We have not registered any violations in the polling stations we visited. Former Senator of Uruguay
- 16:19 Ashot Ghoulyan holds meeting with observers from United States and Canada
- 15:30 Nagorno Karabakh denies opening fire at Azerbaijani shepherds
- 14:49 Democratic processes taking place in Artsakh incomparable with "democratic" processes taking place in Azerbaijan. Sharmazanov
- 14:36 Artsakh recognition a matter of time: Sharmazanov
- 14:01 Azerbaijan First Lady is appointed First Vice President
- 13:26 The results of the referendum are excellent: Austrian representative
- 12:02 Russian Delegation is sure that Artsakh can have Independence
- 11:58 Bako Sahakyan received members of the Armenian delegation
- 11:53 MEP: Karabakh breathes with democracy and freedom
- 09:41 Azerbaijani forces intensively fire sniper rifles in NK line of contact
- 09:33 NKR National Assembly Chairman Ashot Ghoulyan received the parliamentary delegation of Armenia
- 09:26 87.6% vote in favor of Constitutional reforms in Nagorno Karabakh
- 09:08 Ashot Ghoulyan holds meeting with the representatives of Basque Country
- 21:37 NKR Foreign Minister receives MEPs Frank Engel and Jaromir Stetina
- 21:09 NKR Foreign Minister discusses activities of “The Nagorno Karabakh Forum” in Uruguay with former senator
- 21:01 NKR Foreign Minister discusses expansion of relations with Belgian parliamentarians
- 02.18.2017 Turks have put Christian cross on footwear soles
- 02.23.2017 Nagorno Karabakh soldier shot dead
- 02.21.2017 87.6% vote in favor of Constitutional reforms in Nagorno Karabakh
- 02.20.2017 Voting on constitutional referendum kicks off in NKR
- 02.21.2017 Russian Delegation is sure that Artsakh can have Independence
- 02.18.2017 Azerbaijan fired mortar shells at night
- 02.18.2017 Refugees of different faiths find help in LA Armenian church
- 02.20.2017 More people will live in Talish village than before April 2016. Bako Sahakyan
- 02.21.2017 Azerbaijani forces intensively fire sniper rifles in NK line of contact
- 02.22.2017 Defense minister Sargsyan mentions Iskander engagement conditions